Re-Claiming the Bible for a Non-Religious World
by Andy Hanson
HarperCollins Publishers, 2011
by John Shelby Spong
Reviewed by Andy Hanson
Let me preface this review with the following caution: If yours is an unshakable belief that the Bible is literally the word of God, read no further. If it's your belief that you are putting your soul in jeopardy by reading “heresy,” as defined by the 28 fundamental doctrines of the Adventist church, read no further. If you believe that Ellen White's biblical commentary will resolve any questions that might occur to you as you read the stories and history and poetry and wisdom literature and drama and prophecies and apocalyptic chapters in the biblical record, read no further.
If you believe that only the Adventist Church is capable of correctly determining “right” beliefs and behavior, read no further. If you believe that reading this book might force you to decide between godless evolution and Christian faith, read no further. And finally, if you believe that I am under the influence of demonic powers for suggesting that you open your Bible and read along with Spong’s Bible commentary, read no further.
If you're still with me, I have provided a Publisher’s Weekly review of the book. Following the review, there are two links: One will allow you to browse a significant portion of the book without charge; the other connects you to a YouTube interview with the author.
For most Adventists, an intellectual engagement with Spong’s ideas becomes a debate with a very skillful disputant. I believe that you will find the contest exhilarating and your faith enlivened.
“Episcopal bishop Spong, author of more than 20 books, may be retired, but he hasn’t stopped. His newest grows from a series of summer lectures that clue the people in the pews on the kinds of topics biblical scholars discuss among themselves: for example, biblical characters such as Judas and Joseph, Jesus’ earthly dad, appear to be literary creations.
“Everybody who hasn’t abruptly left the room on hearing it suggested that the Bible may not be literally true is in for a wonderful ride as Spong tours Christianity’s sacred text, leaving little unexamined and demythologized as he urges Christians to grow up and take the Bible seriously—just not literally. Spong’s arguments aren’t new, but he has the gift and motivation for making biblical scholarship accessible; he writes with charity and clarity. His fans will want this for Bible study groups; his detractors may simply decide that Spong, still unwelcome, is being his heretical self once again.”
https://www.publishersweekly.com/978-0-06-201128-2
Browse Inside Re-Claiming the Bible for a Non-Religious World
https://www.amazon.com/Re-Claiming-Bible-Non-Religious-World-Shelby/dp/0062011286/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1331879384&sr=1-1#reader_0062011286
A Spong YouTube Interview
Bishop Spong deplores the way the Bible has been used to justify most of the world's evils; from gender inequality, homosexuality and child abuse, to capital punishment, destruction of the environment, and the evils of birth control. In the interview, he discusses the rise of Muslim Fundamentalism and laments that congregations at mainstream churches are in freefall. (Originally aired May 2005)
Though I may not share Spong's views on the historocity of the Bible, I totally agree that most of us are far more concerned in proving it to be literally true than we are with what the stories mean. We can lose site of their real truth when we become obsessed with proving they actually happened as stated in every detail.
Spong is no more objective than the rest of us, and has a personal belief system to share since he has given his life to his study. It's interesting that the Bible is felt to be less reliable by certain scholars than other ancient histories.
But he is right if he is saying we put the literal above the meaning and interpret it out of its context.