Another False Argument
by Andy Hanson
Note from the editor: This column assumes the correctness of the documentary hypothesis (DH), although the DH is not accepted by most Seventh-day Adventists and has undergone much variation and controversy in the non-Adventist biblical scholarly world.
by Andy Hanson, August 24, 2014
In the Adventist Review of July 24, 2014, Cliff Goldstein presented "Another (False) Argument Against a Six-Day Creation," in which he attacked the argument that the six-day creation story in Genesis 1 is a mythic or poetical account of creation because “mornings and evenings” occurred before the creation of the sun and moon on the “fourth” creation day.
Cliff argues that “this contrast [gives] the Spirit-inspired reader more reasons to accept Genesis 1 and 2 as a literal account of the six-day creation of our world.”
Yet he wrote what he did about day one, day two, and day three existing before the appearance of “the greater light” on day four? Why would Moses, or anyone, write a creation story that went so blatantly against what was one of the most obvious features of the natural world as we humans experience it: the dominance of the sun in determining the arrival and departure of each day?
Scripture was written so that people would believe it; thus, why would the author write an account so counter to everyday experience unless God told it to him? We don’t know exactly how the Lord revealed the truths of Genesis 1 and 2 to Moses, but Moses might have been as baffled as we are about the existence of day and night before the appearance of the sun on day four. That’s why one could argue that it was truth revealed to him; otherwise, who would concoct something so contrary to what humans experience on a daily basis?
Where to begin? (1) The idea that Moses wrote this creation account is ludicrous. (2) The notion that this story is a literal account of the creation of the universe—sun, moon, stars—is also beyond imagining. (3) Finally, this creation story is a poem.
(1) Moses was born in Egypt on the 7th of Adar of the year 2368 from creation (1393 BCE), at a time when the Israelites were slaves to the rulers of the land and subject to many harsh decrees.1
Although tradition attributes Genesis to Moses,2 biblical scholars hold that it, together with the following four books (making up what Jews call the Torah3 and biblical scholars call the Pentateuch) is "a composite work, the product of many hands and periods."4 A common hypothesis among biblical scholars today is that the first major comprehensive draft of the Pentateuch was composed in the late 7th or the 6th century BC (the Jawhist source5), and that this was later expanded by the addition of various narratives and laws (the Priestly source6) into a work very like the one existing today.7 The two sources appear in reverse order: (Genesis 1:1–2:3 ESV) is Priestly, and (Genesis 2:4–24 ESV) is Jahwistic.
As for the historical background which led to the creation of the narrative itself, a theory which has gained considerable interest, although still controversial, is "Persian imperial authorization." This proposes that the Persians, after their conquest of Babylon8 in 538 BC, agreed to grant Jerusalem a large measure of local autonomy within the empire, but required the local authorities to produce a single law code9 accepted by the entire community. It further proposes that there were two powerful groups in the community – the priestly families who controlled the Temple, and the landowning families who made up the "elders" – and that these two groups were in conflict over many issues, and that each had its own "history of origins," but the Persian promise of greatly increased local autonomy for all provided a powerful incentive to cooperate in producing a single text.10
(2) The universe of the Hebrew Bible11 was made up of a flat disc-shaped earth12 floating on water, heaven13 above, underworld14 below.15 Only in Hellenistic16 times (after c. 330 BCE) was the older three-level cosmology widely replaced by the Greek concept of a spherical earth17 suspended in space18 at the center19 of a number of concentric heavens.20 21
(3) When we read Genesis chapter one we usually see only one story there, but there are actually many stories. Why don't we see these multiple stories? Because we read the Hebrew Bible from a Modern Western thinker's point of view and not from an Ancient Eastern thinker's, such as that of the Hebrews who wrote it. The Hebrews’ style of writing is prolific with a style of poetry unfamiliar to most readers of the Bible. This poetry is nothing like the poetry we are used to reading today, and therefore it is invisible to us.
The most common form of Hebrew poetry is called parallelism. Parallelism is when the writer says one thing in two or more different ways. The Psalms and Proverbs are filled with these, such as the examples below.
Psalms 119:105 – "Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light for my path." The first part of this verse is paralleled with the second part. This verse is not saying two different things; rather, one thing in two different ways.
Proverbs 3:1 – "My son, do not forget my teaching, and keep my commands in your heart." Again the first part is paralleled with the second part.
Genesis 4:23 – Lamech said to his wives, "Adah and Zillah, listen to me; wives of Lamech, hear my words. I have killed a man for wounding me and a young man for injuring me."
Let's break down what Lamech says; [Adah and Zillah, listen to me] = [wives of Lamech, hear my words] then he says; I have killed [a man for wounding me] = [a young man for injuring me]. Lamech did not wound one and injure another, but killed one person and says it two different ways.
Often we overlook what the Bible is telling us because we are not recognizing what the poetry of a passage is attempting to convey. For example, look at Psalm 40:8; "I desire to do your will, O my God; your Torah is within my heart." Here we see that doing the will of God is the same thing as having the Torah within your heart.
Now let us look at the Creation story parallels of Genesis chapter one.
Creation Story Number 1
The first story is found in Genesis 1:1: "In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth." The Hebrew word "bara" is a verb and is usually translated as "create." To really understand what this word means, let us look at another passage where this word is used.
1 Samuel 2:29 – Why do you scorn my sacrifice and offering that I prescribed for my dwelling? Why do you honor your sons more than me by fattening yourselves on the choice parts of every offering made by my people Israel?' The word "fattening" in the passage above is the Hebrew word "bara." The noun form of this verb is "beriya" and can be found in Genesis 41:4 – "And the cows that were ugly and gaunt ate up the seven sleek, fat cows." The word "fat" is the Hebrew word "beriya."
The word "bara" does not mean, "create" (Hebrew actually has no word that means "create" in the sense of something out of nothing) but "to fatten.” If we take the literal definition of "bara'" in Genesis 1:1 we have – In the beginning God fattened the heavens and the earth. What does this fattening of the heavens and earth mean? This verse is not showing the creation of the heaven and earth, but rather the fattening or filling up of it. Therefore, Genesis 1:1 is a condensed version of the whole creation story.
Creation Story Number 2
The second creation story paralleling Genesis 1:1 is Genesis 1:2 – "and the earth was unfilled and empty and darkness was over the face of the deep, and the Wind of God was hovering over the waters." In this passage we see that the earth was formless and empty before it was filled up, then the Wind of God hovers over the waters of the earth. This hovering would be the action of the Wind of God filling up the earth.
The use of the word "and" at the beginning of this verse may cause some confusion due to an understanding of how this word is used in Hebrew. In English the word "and" in between verses one and two means that what happens in verse two occurs after what happens in verse one. In Hebrew, the word "and" is used in standard Hebrew poetry to link two statements as one. In other words, verse one is the same thing as verse two.
Creation Story Number 3
The third story is found in Genesis 1:3-5. "And God said, 'Let there be light,' and there was light, and God saw that the light was good, and he separated the light from the darkness, and God called the light 'day,' and the darkness he called 'night,' and there was evening, and there was morning, the first day."
Hebrew, like English, has a word for one and a different word for first. The same is true for the words two and second, three and third, etc. As an example, the Hebrew word for "three" is "shelosh," and the Hebrew word for "third" is "sheliyshiy." Days 2 – 7 use the Hebrew word for second, third, fourth, etc. We would assume that the "first" day would use the Hebrew word "reshon" meaning "first" in order to be consistent with the other six days, but instead we have the word "echad," meaning "one" or " in unity." The author is making a parallel with the "first" day and with all the days of creation. I believe this is because all seven days of the fattening of the earth are being united in this verse. The first day of creation is also a parallel with the whole of creation, as the earth was in darkness and the act of filling the earth brought light to the earth.
Creation Story Number 4
The fourth creation story is found in Genesis 1:3-13. In these passages we have the first three days of creation. These are the days of separating. On the first day God separated light from darkness. On the second day God separated the waters above from the waters below, forming the sky and the seas. On the third day God separated the land from the water, forming dry land.
Creation Story Number 5
The fifth creation story is found in Genesis 1:14-31. In these passages we have the second set of three days of creation. On the fourth day God filled the light with the sun, and the darkness with the moon and stars. On the fifth day God filled the sky with the birds and the sea with the fish. On the sixth day God filled the dry land with the animals and man. Notice the correlation between the first set of three days of separation with the second set of three days of filling.
Creation Story Number 6
The sixth story is the whole of Genesis chapter one. Though we have looked at five different stories of creation, they are all combined together to form one complete story of creation.
Modern western thinkers view events in step logic, which is the idea that each event comes after the previous, forming a series of events in a linear timeline. But the Hebrews did not think in step logic; they thought in block logic. This is the grouping together of similar ideas together and not in chronological order. Most people read Genesis chapter one from a step logic perspective, or chronological, rather than from the block logic so prevalent in Hebrew poetry.22